Fraud and breach of trust under French law: what are the differences?

4
temps de lecture
/
17/11/2026
Fraud and breach of trust under French law: what are the differences?
Prendre contact avec une avocate en droit pénal des affaires

Agathe Lengereau

A director discovers that an administrative manager has used company funds to pay personal expenses.

A few weeks later, another company learns that a fake service provider, posing as a long-standing partner, obtained a large transfer thanks to falsified documents.

In both situations, the harm is real. But legally, are we talking about breach of trust (abus de confiance) or fraud (escroquerie)?

As a business criminal law lawyer in Paris, I regularly assist directors faced with these situations. Here is what you need to understand, in concrete terms, about the differences between breach of trust and fraud, their risks and the reflexes to adopt.

Breach of trust and fraud in France: two offences against property

A common feature: an attack on the company’s assets

Breach of trust and fraud are two offences provided for by the French Criminal Code which protect above all the property rights of others.

In both cases:

  • property, funds or valuables are misappropriated;
  • the company suffers financial loss;
  • criminal proceedings may be brought;
  • the legal entity may join the proceedings as a civil party (partie civile).

But the central difference lies in the reason why the property was handed over and the moment at which the fraudulent act occurs.

‍

Breach of trust: the betrayal of a lawful handover

Legal definition

Article 314-1 of the French Criminal Code defines breach of trust as:

“the act by a person of misappropriating, to the prejudice of others, funds, valuables or any property that were handed over to him and that he accepted subject to the condition of returning them, handing them back or using them in a specified way.”

In other words:

The property was lawfully handed over, without any initial deception.

The fraudulent act occurs after the handover.

The constituent elements of breach of trust

To establish a breach of trust, four elements must be present.

1. A prior lawful handover

The victim voluntarily entrusts the property to the perpetrator, for example:

  • under a contract (agency, deposit, management),
  • in an employment relationship,
  • in a relationship between partners,
  • as part of an assignment given to a service provider.

The handover takes place in complete trust, without any prior deceptive manoeuvre.

2. A handover on a precarious basis (and not as owner)

The property is handed over subject to the condition of returning it, handing it back or using it in a specified way; the perpetrator is not the owner but a precarious holder (détenteur précaire).

The perpetrator must therefore, for example, return the property or use it for a specified purpose.

3. A misappropriation

The perpetrator uses the property in a manner contrary to the agreed purpose, causing harm.

For example:

  • cashing cheques, which a client had handed to a financial adviser for investment purposes, into the adviser’s personal account,
  • a cash withdrawal using a bank card lent by an elderly person to a home carer for the purpose of doing shopping,
  • keeping a rented item after the end of the rental period.

It is this misappropriation that constitutes the material element of the offence.

4. Fraudulent intent

Poor management or a simple delay is not enough.

There must be a deliberate intention on the part of the perpetrator to appropriate the property or to use it in breach of its original purpose.

Frequent examples in business

In practice, breach of trust concerns in particular:

  • an employee who misappropriates funds entrusted to him or her;
  • an administrative director who, thanks to his or her access rights, transfers money to a personal account;
  • the renter of a vehicle who does not return it at the end of the rental period.

In these situations, trust existed beforehand. It is precisely this trust that is betrayed.

Key points to remember

The handover is lawful.

The fraudulent act occurs after the handover.

The perpetrator misappropriates property that he or she held lawfully.

‍

Fraud: deception to bring about the handover

Legal definition

Article 313-1 of the French Criminal Code defines fraud as the act, whether by:

  • using a false name,
  • using a false capacity,
  • abusing a genuine capacity,
  • using fraudulent manoeuvres,

“of deceiving a natural or legal person and thereby inducing that person, to his or her prejudice or to the prejudice of another, to hand over funds, valuables or any property, to provide a service or to consent to an act creating an obligation or a discharge.”

Here, the logic is reversed:

The fraudulent act occurs before the handover and brings it about.

The constituent elements

1. A voluntary but vitiated handover

The victim hands over the funds voluntarily but his or her consent is vitiated by the deception.

Without the manoeuvre, he or she would never have handed over the property.

2. Fraudulent means

The offence requires one of the following means: a false name, a false capacity, abuse of a genuine capacity or fraudulent manoeuvres (staging, forged documents, organised scenarios, etc.).

3. A causal link

The manoeuvres must have been decisive in the handover. In other words, without the fraudulent means, the victim would not have made the handover.

4. Fraudulent intent

The perpetrator knows that he or she is deceiving in order to obtain the thing coveted, which may be property but also a service or an act.

Typical examples for a business

  • A fake supplier requesting a transfer,
  • Presentation of falsified balance sheets to obtain a contract,
  • CEO fraud (fraude au président) targeting the accounting department.

In these cases, trust is created artificially.

‍

Breach of trust or fraud: the essential differences

The timing of the fraudulent act

  • Breach of trust: the fraudulent act occurs after the handover.
  • Fraud: the fraudulent act occurs before the handover.

The nature of the handover

  • Breach of trust: lawful and precarious handover.
  • Fraud: handover brought about by deception.

The material element

  • Breach of trust: misappropriation or misuse of property already lawfully held, on a precarious basis.
  • Fraud: fraudulent manoeuvres (or a false name, false capacity or abuse of a genuine capacity) that bring about the handover.

Why does the legal classification matter?

The criminal classification affects in particular:

  • the strategy for filing a complaint,
  • the evidence to be produced,
  • the criminal liability of the persons involved.

‍

What penalties and what risks?

Both offences are currently punishable by:

  • 5 years’ imprisonment,
  • a €375,000 fine.

Aggravating circumstances may increase the sentence.

Possible additional penalties

  • a ban on managing a company;
  • a ban on practising a profession;
  • confiscation;
  • display or publication of the judgment.

‍

What should you do if you suspect breach of trust or fraud?

If your company is the victim

  1. Immediately secure the evidence.
  2. Carry out a discreet internal audit.
  3. Assess the overall loss.
  4. File a complaint.

You can read my dedicated article on filing a criminal complaint for a company.

A well-constructed strategy makes it possible to:

  • improve the chances of success of the investigation,
  • increase the chances of obtaining compensation,
  • protect reputation.

If you are the subject of allegations

You should:

  • analyse the classification precisely,
  • anticipate internal communication,
  • organise the criminal defence in an attempt to limit the criminal sentence and the damages to be paid to the potential victim.

You can read our article on the criminal liability of company directors to understand the mechanisms that apply.

‍

In practice for your business

- Put strict internal procedures in place.

- Secure payment approval channels.

- Train teams on the risks of fraud.

- Provide for a criminal crisis management protocol.

Prevention reduces exposure to risk.

‍

Conclusion

The difference between breach of trust and fraud rests on a simple question:

Was the property handed over lawfully or obtained by deception?

In practice, however, situations are often complex.

The stakes go far beyond the criminal classification alone.

They affect:

  • the liability of the director,
  • the company’s reputation with its own staff,
  • its reputation with its partners and clients,
  • brand image.

As a business criminal law lawyer in Paris (France), I regularly assist directors, legal departments and companies faced with situations of breach of trust or fraud, whether:

  • for the defence,
  • as a civil party.

‍

Get in touch
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! An error occurred while submitting the form. Please refresh the page and try again.